Sentencing Jehovah's Witness is Violation of Freedom of Religion

On the 23rd of December the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) and its member organisation "Civil Society Institute" NGO (CSI) spread a joint statement condemning the sentencing of Jehovah's witness, Andranik Makvetsyan, to 6 months of imprisonment.

"Our organisations believe that the verdict in Andranik Makvetsyan's case was motivated by the fact that he is a member of the Jehovah's Witnesses' religious organisation", states the joint statement.

According to FIDH and CSI this verdict violates Article 26 (Freedom of Religion) of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia, in a general context of pressure against religious minorities.

As a reminder, on the 28th of November 2011, Judge Tigran Petrosyan, of the Court of General Jurisdiction of Malatia and Sebastia sentenced Andranik Makvetsyan, under the Article 143.1 (Breach of citizens' legal equality) of the Criminal Code of Armenia.

On the 15th of May 2011, members of the Jehova's Witness religious organisation, Andranik Makvetsyan and Samvel Grigoryan, were preaching to two citizens in the vicinity of the Holy Trinity Church of Yerevan. Priest Ter Yesayi Artak Artenyan ordered the preachers to leave, which led to a quarrel with Andranik Makvetsyan.

On the 17th of May 2011 a criminal case was instituted against Andranik Makvetsyan, who was charged under Articles 118 (Battery), 322.1 (Arbitrariness) and 137.1 (Threats of murder, causing grave harm to health, or property destruction) of the Armenian Criminal Code.

However, on the 21st of October the Prosecutor amended the charges, adding a new charge under Article 143.1 (Breach of citizens' legal equality).

The Court found that Andranik Makvetsyan had violated Article 8.1 (State-Church relationship) and Article 14.1 (Equality before the law) of the Armenian Constitution , stating that "Andranik Makvetsyan violated the right of the victim, Priest Ter Yesayi Artenyan, to hinder attempts to involve people in the Jehova's Witnesses organization and advocate in the vicinity of the church.

Therefore, the acts committed by Andranik Makvetsyan qualify as a crime under Article 143.1 of the Criminal Code.

"Nevertheless, our organisations consider that Articles 8.1 and 14.1 cannot be applicable to the quarrel at issue. Moreover, Article 8.1 of the Armenian Constitution regulating State - Church relationships does not envisage any individual right that could have been breached", says the announcement.